Alive....
Surgery was successful, though sitting is still difficult. I get my stent out on Friday. If all goes well, I'll be back to work on the 16th. Things are looking up from here.
Surgery
I started bleeding again yesterday and it's persisted into this evening. This is troublesome since I'm supposed to go under the knife again in 7 hours.
I'll know more tomorrow obviously.
In the meantime, here is a reminder that good weather is no more than a month away.
1
Ow. Get well soon, Brikmuppet! And tell them to give you the good stuff this time.
Posted by: Pixy Misa at Mon Mar 6 07:34:14 2017 (PiXy!)
2
I think Android has learned spelling from BvS...
Posted by: Pixy Misa at Mon Mar 6 07:35:05 2017 (PiXy!)
3
I have just received a series of texts and a phone call from friend Brickmuppet. He made it through the surgery perfectly fine, though the anesthesia has yet to entirely wear off... apparently his arms and legs are moving in ways not commanded, but his fingers are fine.
He'll be incommunicado for Monday, and maybe Tuesday. But no matter, he's as good as it's possible to be after a surgery of the sort he had!
Posted by: Wonderduck at Mon Mar 6 23:42:30 2017 (UDOXQ)
Most of the articles linked in the NBF post are from last year and the post focuses on the tsunami aspect of the weapon, which is not likely to be that much of a strategic threat.
For those unfamiliar with this most clickbaity of weapons, "Status 6" is a new Russian torpedo carrying a nuclear warhead. Nothing new there except that this torpedo is over 5 feet wide and nearly 80 feet long and the warhead is between 50 and 150 megatons, with 100 megatons being the general consensus. The torpedo is big enough to carry the 100 megaton "Tsar Bomba" or RDS 220 physics package which was tested at half yield back in the 1960s producing 57 megatons of 'splody and cracking windows over 200 miles away.
It is designed to be fired into harbors, rendering them unuseable due to cratering and radioactive contamination. In the semi-enclosed waters of San Fransisco and San Diego bays, Puget Sound and possibly the Chesapeake Bay seiche effects would likely result in impressive wave heights, but the energies released by this weapon pale in comparison to what an earthquake releases and you can't just blow one up offshore and devastate the coast.
However, the effect is not nonexistant.
Table from here. A 22-74 foot wave 100 miles away is kind of scary.
The bigger concern is the blast and radiation, even if not salted with cobalt 60 or something a high yield version of the old RDS220 would be horrifically radioactive. From the Nuclear Weapon Archive article...
The effect of this bomb at full yield on global fallout would have been tremendous. It would have increased the world's total fission fallout since the invention of the atomic bomb by 25%.
Since the effects of a ground burst are orders of magnitude worse for radioactive contamination than an airburst, the effect on the targeted harbors and those downwind is likely to be so dreadful that cobalt is unnecessary.
There are 2 operational carriers of this delightful piece of technology, one is an experimental submarine that has one monstrous torpedo tube for this weapon. There is also a converted cruise missile submarine that reportedly has six tubes, though it is a combination spy- sub and work boat. In a year or so, the purpose built Khabarovsk comes into service, which will carry at least 6 tubes.
Assume 1 is hitting Pearl Harbor, 2 were used n Puget Sound because of the geography, the SSBN base OR the cities can be hit, but not both. Targets are major commercial ports and the most important naval bases. I assumed that no subs were in the gulf of Mexico, but they do have one addition sub to shoot at New Orleans. Additionally, certain Inland ports like Sacramento or Albany might be fairly easy shots for this weapon if maximum fallout is desired.
..the thing that is most striking is the sheer size of the affected areas, even not taking into account the fallout. The fireball that plasmaglobe of utter destruction in the center of a nuclear blast is 10 miles across. The orange area is where fires would be started on a clear day and the lightest shade of grey is the 1.5 psi area where all the windows are blown out, the darker shades of grey has most homes demolished and inside that it's...unpleasant.
For scale I nuked Washington DC with a B-83, the most powerful weapon in the U.S. arsenal. It doesn't really show up at this scale.
Of course if the Russians actually used these, they'd be using their other nuclear weapons too, but the sheer amount if devastation caused by 11 of these things on CONUS ports is kind of sobering.
A Magnetic Field for Mars, on a Budget
Mars has lost the bulk of it's atmosphere in part because it's magnetic field is weak and only covers parts of its tropical regions. This has allowed the solar wind to strip away most of the planet's atmosphere other than the relatively dense CO2.
Therefore, one issue facing those who would terraform the red planet is the fact that if the atmosphere were built up through human endeavors, the atmosphere would immediately start to erode again, taking thing like the oxygen and nitrogen first.
Giving the planet a magnetic field has been considered a far more daunting task than simply terraforming it, since to increase the output of the planetary dynamo would require bringing a large moon to pull on its core like ours does.
This has...practicality issues.
One alternative is a vast series of cables built all over the red planet and powered by many gigawats of electricity. Such a system has been proposed for Earth to deal with a possible pole reversal.
"That's less than one quarter of a typical MRI machine's maximum capacity."
Uh...thanks.
Anyway, the magnetic field generated would deflect the solar wind around the planet, rather more completely than Earths field does, since the field is separate and doesn't leave the poles unprotected.
This would, even without any further human intervention, result in the Martian atmosphere thickening on its own.
This makes any terraforming of Mars much more sustainable.
We here at Brickmuppet Blog are more of the Dandridge Cole, Gerard K. O'Neal schools of space settlement, but this is a really neat development. A planetary settlement does have some advantages with regards to resources, especially on a place like Mars.
(Interestingly, this probably can't be made to work with regards to Earth, because our Lagrange Points are not balanced between Earth and the sun, but rather Earth and the Moon.)
Posted by: Wonderduck at Sun Mar 5 21:25:27 2017 (UDOXQ)
2
1. On the first hand, once you're out of the gravity well, stay out of the gravity well.
2. On the second hand, planets are targets.
3. Gripping hand? Gengeneer for freefall.
Posted by: Clayton Barnett at Sun Mar 5 21:32:43 2017 (ug1Mc)
3
Re: practicality issues. How massive, and how close (presumably a trade-off situation) would said moon have to be? Solar sails could probably be used to brake a largish asteroid and drop it into a lower orbit. Or nukes could do the same thing. Calculate the trajectory carefully and the asteroid become Mars' new moon.
Posted by: jabrwok at Mon Mar 6 09:57:32 2017 (BlRin)
4
The paper posits that you would put it at the L1 point, which is a fixed distance. The enegy level of the magnetic field is, as pointed out, not very high, but presumably it does need a fairly large area. The main question I would have: what kind of push would you be getting from the solar wind, and what does that mean in terms of making a large array rigid and having thrusters to keep it in place?
Posted by: David at Mon Mar 6 18:25:42 2017 (JMkaQ)
UPDATE:J. Greely suggests that this story may be dubiously sourced. If it turns out to be apocryphal, it would still warrant the word "ignominious", but in a slightly different context.
Wah-hoo-oo!
They're rebooting...Duck Tales? This is an odd choice in art styles, but it looks surprisingly...well I do not immediately despise this development.
1
Looks rather like the art style used in "Samuri Jack", though somewhat modernised...
Posted by: TJ at Fri Mar 3 11:54:41 2017 (A4T95)
2
And of course, the cast would not be complete without adding a girl, who is going to be hyper smart and good at everything I'm sure.
I wouldn't say Samurai Jack, but I am flashing on a style you might have seen in the '50's or '60's. Don't have a name for it really, but it seems familiar.
Posted by: Mauser at Fri Mar 3 21:36:01 2017 (5Ktpu)
3
The original one had a girl (Gabbigale? I think?) but she was not so "spunky" (read: annoying) as this one promises to be.
I dunno. From some angles the art style looks more harking back to the old comic books, from others it looks definitely Looney Tunes.
The biggest thing, though....I know Alan Young has gone on to his reward but I cannot get used to the new voice they have given to Scrooge.
Posted by: fillyjonk at Fri Mar 3 21:40:48 2017 (8Ov9m)
4
Oh, you're right, I had mostly forgotten her. She was more of a child then - annoying little sister, babytalker, source of trouble. I still stand by my prediction she's going to be the "Smart one."
Oh, and stylistically, I'm reminded of some of the Ludvig von Drake shorts.
Posted by: Mauser at Sat Mar 4 17:33:22 2017 (5Ktpu)
(STILL waiting for the boxed DVDs of Aladdin., They did the rest of the Disney Afternoon series....)
Posted by: Mauser at Sat Mar 4 17:35:48 2017 (5Ktpu)
6
Webbigail. Used to engage a female audience for a show strongly geared for a male audience. Also a way to open up the stories a bit more, as Scrooge and the nephews were fairly one-dimensional, from what I remember.
I grew bored with Duck Tales quickly, and never cared for Rescue Rangers, but really enjoyed TaleSpin.
7Darkwing Duck. That was the one I enjoyed. Though I fear a reboot would find some way of spoiling it. (TaleSpin was good, too)
Posted by: fillyjonk at Sun Mar 5 08:58:03 2017 (8Ov9m)
8
Gargoyles was also from around that time frame. Lots of Star Trek TNG cast did voice work in that one.
Posted by: Will at Sun Mar 5 20:56:14 2017 (dw88k)
9
Duck Tales eventually became Darkwing Duck, which was, frankly the best superhero show on TV for some years. I agree with Fillyjonk thjat DWD was the better show, but Duck Tales was well done in it's own right.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Sun Mar 5 21:15:55 2017 (KicmI)
10
Gargoyles was a bit later I think. It was surprisingly good as well.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Sun Mar 5 21:20:17 2017 (KicmI)
11
Pretty much everything Tad Stones touched was gold. (Darkwing Duck had a few in-jokes for the fan mailing list too.)
Posted by: Mauser at Mon Mar 6 23:53:12 2017 (5Ktpu)
Holy Crap! This Movie Actually Got Made!
It's looks to be a low budget film and of course it's being pretty much buried by hollywood and is thus floundering in limited release, but it's actually in theaters now!
1
I gather the board pushed him out of the company in late 2015 because they wanted fresh blood, then sued him when he launched a competing magazine/site/etc in late 2016. I'll refrain from using the first descriptive phrase that comes to mind, given your current condition...
-j
Posted by: J Greely at Tue Feb 28 00:48:50 2017 (tgyIO)
Posted by: Rick C at Tue Feb 28 09:54:24 2017 (ECH2/)
3
RickC, this actually makes sense, given her backstory. Oh, the opposite sides bit is a touch over-the-top, but both having a single horn pulls nicely from the source material.
Posted by: Wonderduck at Tue Feb 28 23:01:27 2017 (UDOXQ)
4
Well, a lot of that stinks. But the rest is not as bad as it could be. (Which is not saying much, but some days, that has to be enough.)
Posted by: Suburbanbanshee at Fri Mar 3 21:52:48 2017 (S0Svy)
Milo
The Milo story broke as I was preparing to go into the hospital and I only became aware of it in the waiting room. I was horrified...though not as much as I was 2 days later.
A bit of background:
Milo Yiannopoulos is an exuberantly gay Catholic Briton of Jewish decent with a black boyfriend. Milo is also a loud, obnoxious, rude and crude advocate for free speech and vocal opponent of both government and corporate censorship.
Naturally this assortment of characteristics got him pegged as a NAZI.
Obnoxious, rude and crude don't actually do him justice, as he has had a tendency to be sadistically catty in a way that only urbane queens can pull off. In his case this caused some anxiety because as we all know, gay men are not actually people, but a variety of animatronic fetish dolls whose only legitimate functions are to provide upper middle class white women with affirmation of their grandeur and opportunities for virtue signaling.
Sadly, Milo did not fulfill this important societal niche, at least not in the approved way. He did not turn his poison tongue against working class pizza waitresses of limited means, but rather against hollywood celebrities, as well as powerful lobbyists and activists in the gaming industry. He said some things that I think were rude and unescessary, and he hurt his argument sometimes through the exquisite sadism of his insults.
He also tended to be on the bad side of some truly loathsome individuals as seen in his habit of going after pedophiles and exposing them. Amongst those were Sarah Nyberg, and Chris Leydon and he was an early voice sounding the alarm about Jimmy Savile.
So it was pretty horrifying to learn that an interview of Milo with him advocating for pedophellia had turned up.
It's at least as horrifying that this story appears to be bunk, yet has cost this man his job, his book deal and his good name.
Milo’s money quote, which was edited out of the video, is this: The law is probably about right, that’s probably roughly the right age. I think it’s probably about okay, but there are certainly people who are capable of giving consent at a younger age, I certainly consider myself to be one of them, people who are sexually active younger. I think it particularly happens in the gay world by the way. In many cases actually those relationships with older men…This is one reason I hate the left. This stupid one size fits all policing of culture. (People speak over each other). This sort of arbitrary and oppressive idea of consent, which totally destroys you know understanding that many of us have. The complexities and subtleties and complicated nature of many relationships. You know, people are messy and complex. In the homosexual world particularly. Some of those relationships between younger boys and older men, the sort of coming of age relationships, the relationships in which those older men help those young boys to discover who they are, and give them security and safety and provide them with love and a reliable and sort of a rock where they can’t speak to their parents. Some of those relationships are the most -â€
Well, Milo's been an ass again, but that's hardly a new development. Milo, himself a victim of sexual abuse by a priest, did NOT advocate for pedophelia. He's said numerous times that he considers it to be possibly the worst crime possible.
Milo Yiannopoulos is often not my cup of tea, but he's been nuked from orbit by a false claim and his job, book deal and reputation are currently smouldering ruins.
That bothers me for some reason.
There are a few others who have opinions that diverge from the "It serves him right!" school of thought.
The charges against Milo are contrived from a) video editing and b) rumor and innuendo and c) pretending no one ever used the word "boy†to mean man, thereby meaning playboy is for 10 year olds and "playing with the big boys†means middle schoolers.
IF the attack on Milo were about, say how outrageous he got before the election (he’s been walking it back since. I suspect he gets a little battle mad as I tend to.) I’d shrug and say "whateverâ€. However this is a contrived and false attack and one that apparently came from the right but is teaching the left the way to take every one of us down. You might not like Milo or his lifestyle, but you should not under any circumstances, applaud this means of taking him down. And if you do, I hope you experience likewise and get to experience what you like so much. There is a good chance you will. They’ve tasted blood with Milo. We’re next.
John C Wright (Who, it should be noted is a fairly hardcore social con, going to bat for the gay guy whose being accused of child molestation.)
I have been on the receiving end of a coordinated libel Campaign like this but smaller and not this vicious.
The tactic is simple: simply edit what the victim says to make it sound like he said what you want him to say.
Then you have your Newsmen and paid trolls repeat it.
By the time the truth comes out, everyone already believes the narrative and it’s too late.
I realize that if you have never seen a fake edit job before, it will fool you. What you do to do a fake editing job is take parts of one sentence parts of one conversation and clip them to another. In this case you take a conversation about how many times two college students engaged in copulation are required to ask each other about the continued ongoing state of their consent, and then you clip in a discussion of the consent between a 17 year old and a 27 year old gay couple.
You take a sentence where the speaker uses the word ‘boy’ to refer to a seventeen-year-old and you clip it to a question when someone is asking about a 14 year old boy , clever editing makes it sound as if he is talking about lowering the age of consent to 14
Having unloaded these truths, Milo nevertheless completely agreed that the legal age of consent is a good thing and lands on the right age. The unspoken conclusion driving that statement had to have been that, given the broad spread in age of sexual maturation, it’s appropriate for the law to err on the side of caution to protect the maximum number of children from sexual predators.
Neo Neocon hits on what I think is the real problem with Milo's nosehair curling rant...
As an abuse survivor, Yiannopoulos thinks he can say that consent can be given in such a case, apparently because he thinks he gave it. But that shows one of the problems with sexual abuse, and it’s not just the problem of an adult exploiting a child sexually. It’s the problem of an adult messing with a child’s mind. Because the relationships Yiannopoulos describes are actually betrayals of the child/teen in the guise of "helping†the child, betrayals that may even feel good to the child/teen in certain circumstances but exploit the child/teen’s psychological, emotional, and physical vulnerability.
Kate Paulk's piece contains this brief passage that's almost free of obceneties.
Let me be absolutely clear here. The stickybeaked moralists who are claiming that Milo Yiannopoulos somehow brought this shitstorm on himself because his lifestyle squicks them are endorsing lying to eliminate a person. They are endorsing show trials and guilt by association and all the evils of every fucking Communist regime ever. They are endorsing the tactics both the Soviets and the Nazis used to crush dissenting voices and enemies of the regime.
I'm a southerner and, arguably, a variety of social conservative, so I'm not exactly a Milo fanboy, but I do note that in general, Milo, as a reporter, as well as a rabble rouser, gave considerable discomfort to the powerful, and defended the innocent.
He may well deserve criticism's. Lets make damned sure they are for things he actually did.
1
I just can't get too exercised over Milo. I agree the outrage over what he said has been particularly ginned up to a much greater extent via the use of half-truths and out-of-context screaming headlines. I can't get past the idea that he did, to an identifiable extent, justify sexual relations between people who should know better and people who most often can't and won't know better; on the grounds that a predatory sexual relationship (my words, I understand he doesn't see it that way) is probably just what an abused and misguided child needs. That's how *I* construe what he's said on the issue, not what I've heard he said.
And while I have no problem with defending his statements as a First Amendment issue; even then there is a strong element of "living and dying by the sword" with Milo. Just as with Trump, there is a line that can be crossed from defending one's right to say a thing; and defending what that person has said. Right or not, I strongly suspect that most people won't bother noticing the distinction between the two, and that the defense of Milo is a lost cause, for the moment.
Posted by: Ben at Mon Feb 27 23:13:43 2017 (S4UJw)
Wow! No less than SEVEN planets ranging from roughly Earth to Mars sized have been discovered in the TRAPPIST-1 solar system. No less than three of the planets are in the habitable zone!
All 7, at least theoretically, could have water on their surfaces, though on the farthest planet, any water would almost certainly be ice, and the closest are...borderline. However, at least one of the planets in the habitable region has tentatively been identifies as being of water rich composition (mentioned at about the 04:40 mark in the embedded video).
Note that NASA recently tightened the definition of Habitable Zone which effectively reduced it in width for any given star. This model does not take into account many potential atmospheric effects, but does account for other things. By the older, less restrictive definition (given the distance from the star and sufficient atmospheric pressure, could liquid water exist on the surface of the planet) Venus, Earth, Luna, Mars and Ceres are all in the habitable zone of our solar system. Note too, that under the new rules Earth is a borderline case.
The star is being described an ultra-cool-dwarf, which is NOT a charismatic little person, but a stellar spectral type classification (L-T) that has recently been shoehorned into the demarcation between red dwarf stars and brown dwarfs (which are substellar). The star is only 11% the diameter of the sun or about the size of Jupiter (though much more massive). The orbits of these 7 planets, therefore are pretty close together, kind of like the moons of Jupiter and Saturn, but they are much much larger. This means that...well...look...
From the video, this completely hypothetical view from the fourth planet out is quite speculative and hopeful regarding the snow and water and transparent atmosphere. However, given the latter, is accurate regarding the view of other planets.The other planets, at certain times of year would appear as actual planets rather than wandering points of light. In some cases, planets in adjoining orbits would appear bigger than the moon. The planets are all closer to their tiny, cool star than Mercury is to ours.
Interestingly, while ultracool dwarfs are red stars, that is because so much of their emissions are in the infra-red. Their VISIBLE light from them (or red dwarfs for that matter) would be perceived by us as very similar to our own...basically white-yellow as all the colors are mixed together unless refracted, for example by a prism. (Earth's sun is technically a green star). There are some things missing from their spectrum though, blue and some greens are absent. Thus, optimistically assuming a Nitrogen atmosphere like ours, the nitrogen would not lightly reflect the blue as it does here, thus, the daytime sky would not be blue, but would be transparent. So, if not looking directly at the star, on an optimistically assumed clear day one might well see a black nightlike sky and even see stars (and passing planets) at noon if one was not looking at the star. Green plants, oceans and rainbows would look...different.
They are remarkably similar in size with much less variation than our solar system's rocky planets, ranging from a bit larger than Mars to a tad bigger than Earth. Given the proximity of the planets to one another (as little as 1.5 times the distance to the moon) and super short orbital periods (years on these worlds range from 1.5 to 20 DAYS) they would periodically subject their neighbors to tidal forces, that would provide tides in optimistically supposed seas and perhaps facilitate magnetic fields on the smaller planets in much the same way that Ganymede has one. This would greatly increase the possibility of life. Finally, since we're engaging in highly optimistic ponderings, such tidal forces might interfere with and prevent the assumed tidal locking.
Given current technology, 40 light years might as well be infinity. We could, if we went balls-out and spent something like the budget of the USN for a decade or two, we could make something related to an Orion type starship that could make 5-10 percent the speed of light (max) which would get us to the nearest star (ProximaCentauri at 4.5 light years) in 45-90 years. The Trappist-1 system is a tad under 40 light years away and would be 400-800 years...which is a rather unsatisfactory commute. Still, this discovery is beyond cool and there is the infinitesimal possibility that something like the Alcubierre-drive might be possible and get developed.
Here, one of the Brickmuppet's Crack Team of Science Babes takes a moment to show off the 'work" she's planning on getting done in the hopes that she can one day see this wonder up close.
*There is symmetry in this: The days of the week actually were named after Graeco-Roman astrology, specifically, the 7 classical planets (which included the sun) themselves then named after the high ranking members of the Roman pantheon.
1
Ever since they began using the transit method, we've been discovering scads of extrasolar planets - many of them down to the size which we think makes them likely terrestrial planets. Very cool stuff.
One of the interesting things about the majority of them (discovered by the Kepler telescope) is that many of these M star systems or red dwarf systems seem to have tightly packed planetary systems. Numerous systems have been discovered with very crowded planetary systems. It used to be thought that due to the relative narrowness of the habitable bands in cooler star-systems, that these were unlikely places to find Earthlike worlds. It now seems that they're every bit as good a candidate as hotter G and K stars (and far more plentiful besides).
Posted by: MadRocketSci at Fri Feb 24 22:32:48 2017 (VF34g)
2
Sets of seven open many naming possibilities.
The Seven Deadly Sins.
Gilligan's Island.
The Seven Dwarves.
I'm sure there are others.
Regarding travel times, I kinda *like* the idea of being restricted to STL. Having Earth and her problems several centuries away means not having to deal with the crap the homeland would otherwise try to impose.
Of course I'm still hoping for mass-produced <a href="http://www.iase.cc/openair.htm">Bishop Rings</a> in our Solar System as an interim structure. Every little interest groups could have its own India-sized mini-planet to live on and work out its issues.
Posted by: jabrwok at Sat Feb 25 10:25:08 2017 (BlRin)
Q: "How are we going to call them? Trapists, trapistyans, trapistoids?"
A: "Whatever, as long as it's not `my master'"
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at Sun Feb 26 10:34:33 2017 (XOPVE)
4
Well, Pete, that works not only as a joke, but as a prolog to an epic sci-fi war story (as most Russian humor does).
I further applaud you for your restraint in not taking the low road and making some tasteless joke about the system's inhabitants being traps.
That Could Have Gone Better
There were complications.
A chunk of stone is still lodged in my kidney, and further surgery is needed, in a week or so. I the meantime, I hurt rather a lot and I'm unable to work or go to school.
Surgery in 25 Hours
There's a slim chance that It will be delayed due to the abominable cold I caught nephew-sitting Saturday night. I think I'm almost over it though.
Obviously, blogging will be even lighter for at least a while so here, to tide you over, is an engineer's solution to "the Catbus problem".
Posted by: Pixy Misa at Tue Feb 21 19:41:39 2017 (PiXy!)
2
I hope the surgery goes well (and as scheduled), and that you get back on your feet soon. (I'd be nice if this is your last bout of kidney stones for a good long too, too...) BTW, will this operation be relatively straightforward (e.g. like an appendectomy), or will it be more involved/tricky?
Posted by: Peter the Not-so-Great at Tue Feb 21 23:48:13 2017 (jS1F0)
3
Good luck with your de-stoning! I'm hoping for an easy procedure, an early return to your normal life, and hopefully good news on your school semester. They really need to cut you a break on that one!
Posted by: David at Wed Feb 22 07:20:56 2017 (JMkaQ)
RWBY Season 4 Ends
Well, we're two weeks late in our appraisal, but then, out of 12 full episodes, we managed no more than four other reviews this season as life's interventions caused a substantial delay in watching the show this time around.
Thankfully, it was worth the wait.
"See guys, it says here that we ROCK!"
At mid-season, RWBY's five disparate plotlines began to converge, but not as expected. Instead of having the groups all come together, the various plotlines converged in their tone, with 5 different flavors of existential dread being presented. These, counterintuitively, coincide with the show largely regaining its optimism.
Ruby herself does shine in this season, her pluck and optimism nicely complementing her asskickery. While there is a lot of stuff going on with other characters, at no point in this season do we ask "Hey...isn't there supposed to be a girl in red who is the protagonist?"
Weiss was the least directly traumatized by the horrors of season three's finale, but they dropped her right into the terrible situation that she had fled from three years ago. Weiss's arc this season is almost completely free from violence, but a half second slap manages to be the stuff of nightmares. What she must face is at least as disturbing as anything the others do. Fortunately she has vast reserves of awesome.
Aside from Weiss, Jaune probably wins the charachter development award, though it's a near run thing. He's still a bit out of his depth on the combat front, but he's shallowing rapidly.
We also learn that his upgraded sword now has at least one hidden trick, albeit of short duration and with drawbacks, but that pales in comparison to his growth as a leader and a person.
Blake's skittishness and paranoia are shown to be fully justified, and the show does a good job of portraying the depth of her character and the moral courage she has.
Blake and Sun are a cute couple, even when they argue.
If anyone got shortchanged, it was Yang, but her recovery was both believable and uplifting.
Then there is the farmboy, Oscar, whose predicament puts Ozpin in a whole new and deeply problematic light.
Athough it manages to be heartwarming in a bittersweet way, Ren and Nora's backstory turns out to be as dark as they come. Ren in particular has to cope with....oh wait...
What's this?
FINALLY!
Note that a screen-cap can't actually do justice to just how disturbing this monster is, so I'll just put this here.
Monty would be proud.
The next season looks to be the last and this finale tees it up perfectly. My only complaint at this point is that we've got 8 more months to wait for it.
UPDATE: Rereading the post, I should have mentioned that the ending of this season is not so much a finale, or a cliffhanger as a pause point in the story.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Sun Feb 19 20:25:58 2017 (KicmI)
3
Stopping in the middle of the story, which is almost as bad as a cliffhanger.
I mean, the story itself was good, what we got of it.
Posted by: Rick C at Sun Feb 19 22:42:06 2017 (ITnFO)
4
Oddly, my reaction was that there wasn't a whole lot happening, at least plot-wise, this season. It wasn't quite filler, but there was a lot of backstory and character bits. But in the end the plot boiled down to getting three of the four principals to the same town.
I'm also a little bugged that the grimm basically have a Borg Queen.
Posted by: Mauser at Sun Feb 19 23:42:57 2017 (5Ktpu)
5
I don't think that's what Salem is, unless you meant someone else.
Nonetheless, if we can get people to stop using that stupid "kill the queen and the army dies" trope, that'd be great. I just saw a movie that used that so-called plot this weekend.
Posted by: Rick C at Mon Feb 20 09:48:42 2017 (ECH2/)
6
Oh yeah, I am totally sick of the "Invading army comes with an Insta-win button" plot.
Posted by: Mauser at Mon Feb 20 23:10:38 2017 (5Ktpu)
7
I mean, I get that without that crutch, you can't just build suspense for an hour and 45 minutes and then set up a nice, clean ending in the last 5, but still. How about a little originality?
Posted by: Rick C at Tue Feb 21 00:00:58 2017 (ITnFO)
8
I don't think that's even in play here.
Salem is not the "leader" of the Grimm,
though she may have partially tamed the uprated grim she's making in the pit behind her castle.
If she is killed, the Grim remain as a threat. They are endemic to the planet.
Additionally, one of her top minions might very well take up her mantle for whatever goal she has in mind, or their own.
The White Fang continues with, or without Salem, and is arguably far less constrained if she vanishes.
The raiders, led by Yang's Mom are still a problem, though they might be a lesser one if communications are re-established. They are not allied with Salem in any event (it seems).
The political issues, and the Schnee Dust Company continue even in the absence of Salem.
Salem is a big bad and brings together a lot of disparate evils factions, but she does not appear to be a gordian knot for the worlds problem. Taking her out merely makes the various obnoxious factions independant entities.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Tue Feb 21 16:56:34 2017 (KicmI)
Ouch
I'm still banned from commenting here due to a certain incident in Niue a few years ago, but I've had a knee issue. Knee damage sucks. Send some good wishes and kind thoughts over there.
1
What? I had no idea you were blocked over there. That ain't right. Believe me, Unresolved grudges can eventually bite one.
Posted by: Mauser at Wed Feb 15 00:47:17 2017 (5Ktpu)
2
"a certain incident"
Posted bare URLs instead of using the editor's "insert link" feature, did you?
Posted by: Rick C at Wed Feb 15 11:24:56 2017 (ECH2/)
3
I once tore ACL completely on the right knee (landed on extended leg and buckled it backwards), and one partially on the left knee (landed on my back and stomped it).
Posted by: Pete Zaitcev at Wed Feb 15 14:23:48 2017 (XOPVE)
4
That's exactly what I did to my knee Pete, I feel your pain. That's a long and annoying rehab too.
Posted by: The Brickmuppet at Wed Feb 15 20:14:32 2017 (KicmI)
Hobby Space News of the commercial space industry A Babe In The Universe Rather Eclectic Cosmology Encyclopedia Astronautica Superb spacecraft resource The Unwanted Blog Scott Lowther blogs about forgotten aerospace projects and sells amazingly informative articles on the same. Also, there are cats. Transterrestrial Musings Commentary on Infinity...and beyond! Colony WorldsSpace colonization news! The Alternate Energy Blog It's a blog about alternate energy (DUH!) Next Big Future Brian Wang: Tracking our progress to the FUTURE. Nuclear Green Charles Barton, who seems to be either a cool curmudgeon, or a rational hippy, talks about energy policy and the terrible environmental consequences of not going nuclear Energy From Thorium Focuses on the merits of thorium cycle nuclear reactors WizBang Current events commentary...with a wiz and a bang The Gates of Vienna Tenaciously studying a very old war The Anchoress insightful blogging, presumably from the catacombs Murdoc Online"Howling Mad Murdoc" has a millblog...golly! EaglespeakMaritime security matters Commander Salamander Fullbore blackshoe blogging! Belmont Club Richard Fernandez blogs on current events BaldilocksUnderstated and interesting blog on current events The Dissident Frogman French bi-lingual current events blog The "Moderate" VoiceI don't think that word means what they think it does....but this lefty blog is a worthy read nonetheless. Meryl Yourish News, Jews and Meryls' Views Classical Values Eric Scheie blogs about the culture war and its incompatibility with our republic. Jerry Pournell: Chaos ManorOne of Science fictions greats blogs on futurism, current events, technology and wisdom A Distant Soil The website of Colleen Dorans' superb fantasy comic, includes a blog focused on the comic industry, creator issues and human rights. John C. Wright The Sci-Fi/ Fantasy writer muses on a wide range of topics. Now Read This! The founder of the UK Comics Creators Guild blogs on comics past and present. The Rambling Rebuilder Charity, relief work, roleplaying games Rats NestThe Art and rantings of Vince Riley Gorilla Daze Allan Harvey, UK based cartoonist and comics historian has a comicophillic blog! Pulpjunkie Tim Driscoll reviews old movies, silents and talkies, classics and clunkers. Suburban Banshee Just like a suburban Leprechaun....but taller, more dangerous and a certified genius. Satharn's Musings Through TimeThe Crazy Catlady of The Barony of Tir Ysgithr アニ・ノート(Ani-Nouto) Thoughtful, curmudgeonly, otakuism that pulls no punches and suffers no fools. Chizumatic Stephen Den Beste analyzes anime...with a microscope, a slide rule and a tricorder. Wonderduck Anime, Formula One Racing, Sad Girls in Snow...Duck Triumphalism Beta Waffle What will likely be the most thoroughly tested waffle evah! Zoopraxiscope Too In this thrilling sequel to Zoopraxiscope, Don, Middle American Man of Mystery, keeps tabs on anime, orchids, and absurdities. Mahou Meido MeganekkoUbu blogs on Anime, computer games and other non-vital interests Twentysided More geekery than you can shake a stick at Shoplifting in the Marketplace of Ideas Sounds like Plaigarism...but isn't Ambient IronyAll Meenuvians Praise the lathe of the maker! Hail Pixy!!